AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Secret Affair

by kittynakajima

person FlopJackDan
schedule July 29, 2012 at 12:00 AM
I really enjoy this fanfic, from the moment I read the very first chapter. It's a good thing I started reading it at the beginning of 2012, or I would have gone insane waiting for chapter 19 :)

Is also good to read such an expanded Sonamy story, I mean, I'm not blinded by this couple and I like it when things change around if the story itself is interesting, but (in this site) Sonadow and Shadamy stories had been done to death, whether they are good stories or simplistic one-shots. And I only saw 1 attempt of making a good triangle love thing, that it doesn't seem that it will continue, sadly. So I like that this story tries to stand out, not only with a rarely used couple, but by using a huge amount of effort, and success nicely. Seriously, exact pregnancy information? It may sound boring, but it adds to the inmersion, and I sure as heck like it.

Now, one final thing: After reading chapters 19 and 20, I can see that the story is coming to an end, the closure is yet to come, and the anticipation is there. But, if the story will end just after the "baby" (not to spoil anything) is finally born, could you please make a little epilogue chapter, one where we get to see the lives of Sonic and Amy a few years later? I mean, just to wrap up the story with a nice tie and not leaving room for the "Oh boy, how will their lives be after all this" doubt. If you don't want to do it, and leave the aftermath for the viewer's imagination, then that's fine, but it's something I want you to take in consideration, as I'm sure someone already asked about it, and hell, maybe it crossed your mind at one point, or maybe it didn't.

That's all I wanted to say, hope you keep up with the story!
person Leria
schedule October 22, 2008 at 12:00 AM
The latest chapter was good, but I have to agree with Sonic: this is one time when 'mercy' shouldn't have been given. What should have been done? Sonic should have turned Robotnik into a pile of sentient GOO with Chaos Control, a form where he would never be able to harm anyone ever again.
schedule September 15, 2007 at 12:00 AM
huh.. Its been awhile.. again. Though I don't think I have reveiwed before. First off, the good. Your story here definatly has good emotional build up.. and the tense moments are tense as hell. your grammer is well used, and the characters seem mostly Right personality wise, Albit alittle more emotionaly strained in some cases Then ever in the normal Canon.(sonic, and the Very mad Eggman are examples here.)

to Be a constructive reveiw however, there is the bad which I should Adress.. Unfortunatly Im tired and would rather not search for them. Keep writing, and I'll kep reading.
person Leria
schedule September 6, 2007 at 12:00 AM
Well, I have to say that if Sonic is thinking of killing Eggman, he has the right idea. That idiot has been given chance after chance after chance to turn around and stop trying to take over the world and stop bothering Sonic. Has he done that? No, he just tries EVEN HARDER to kill Sonic and his friends.

Time for Robotnik to be killed, or at least have his brain operated on to get rid of those destructive impulses, even if it means leaving him a vegetable.
person Naxuro
schedule March 14, 2007 at 12:00 AM
This is one awesome fanfic, can't wait to see the ending.
schedule January 30, 2007 at 12:00 AM
NOSE PICKING COWBOYS! Such suspense, such drama, this fic kicks ass. But why the hell doesn't anyone review it!!!? Come on people, get to reviewing! Nearly 4,000 hits and nobody is reviewing? Don't make me track you all down and shoot you!

My reviews are probably getting annoying, but I want you to know that I'm still here, loving your fic! I don't think I've ever been so attached to any other fic as I have this one. Damn, I'm pathetic. Have a wonderful day!
person magebear7
schedule December 11, 2006 at 12:00 AM
not bad. however, there were a couple problems.
1. pov changes. at the end of the chapter, you change from 1st person to 3rd person. the magebear isnt sure if it is intentional or not, just putting it out there.
2. name consistency. throughout the chapter, you switch between "sonic" and "sonikku". now, while only the first is accurate, the magebear can see where you got the other from, so its not a big problem. however, what is a problem is that you use them interchangeably. if you left "sonic" to descriptions and "sonikku" to dialogue, it would be ok. the other way (sonic=dialogue, sonikku=desc) wouldnt make as much sense, but it would work too. as of now, youre using both names for both purposes, which just doesnt work.
3. not as big as the others, but the erotica could be more, well, erotic.
person magebear7
schedule December 11, 2006 at 12:00 AM
dun dun DUN! eggman is arias father! maybe? who knows. anyway, great story!
person Anon
schedule November 3, 2006 at 12:00 AM
Well, well, well...I didn't think that disaster master would have such a sensitive side to him. Nonetheless, Right Here is a good song and I do agree with him that it would make an appropriate theme for this story.

I give your story a 10/10.
person Disaster Master
schedule October 30, 2006 at 12:00 AM
-DM turns to Eggman and pulls out sledge hammer- I'm going to kill you mother fucker! -turns back to story- Great job with ano- oh wait, I forgot about something: KAMIKAZE BABOONS OF TIMBUKTU! Sonic is gonna rip out Eggman's guts and force feed them to him. I would too though if that ever happened to me. Poor Sonic, poor Amy, son of a bitch Eggman! He should've never been born! -DM realizes something- Wait a minute, if it wasn't for Eggman, Sonic and Amy would've never gotten together. -thinks about it a little longer- I still think he's a monkey molester though. I need to know the next part though, so please update as fast as you did this time. And please make "Right Here" by Staind the theme tune for this fic. It's too cute! -DM explodes- Look what you did to me. You made this fic too cute. -DM slaps himself- No, No! It's fine the way it is. Don't get all gorey and brutal. I wish the best to you and your story. Have a wonderful day! ^_^