AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Brothers in Arms

by ktatters

person Komikitty
schedule October 26, 2005 at 12:00 AM
*twitch*
How DARE he?!
With-with OCELOT?
Does the man have NO taste? *Hugs arthur plushie and sighs*
Okay maybe because of Julie he thinks he's got a right but...but...*cries*
A VERY good chapter.
Who the heck is the sabateur?
Are Arthur and John EVER going to get over thier problems?
Will you End the story happily?
INQUIRING MINDS WANT TO KNOOOOWWW!
=^_^=
person Komikitty
schedule October 20, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Yay for updates!
*pouts accusingly* You made it angsty again!
Oh well.
Can't really go anywhere else with a serious and faithful Metal Gear story.
*sigh*
I still wish i could kill Ocelot.
I mean he was cute as a kid.
All Righteous anger and patriotisim, but when he got old...gah. *shudder*
Fantastic Job! *stabs Hal's stepmom*
=^_^=
person Komikitty
schedule September 28, 2005 at 12:00 AM
YAY! You kept your promise! *huggles* Yay! Happiness! and Hal! little Hal! Awwwww! *dances around* And Ocelot got set DOWN! W00T!
...I'd still like to seem him dead but the cockroach refuses to die. *growl* But YAY! John/Arthur forever!
Good luck with the rewrites! Don't stress yourself out to much.
=^_^=
person Komikitty
schedule September 20, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Whaaaat?! You PROMISED! Arthur and John! *sniffle* Poor John...Why are men so STUPID? Poor Arthur, Ocelot you BASTARD! How DARE he?! I'll rip his lungs out and make them into Bagpipes! I'll I'll.....I'll cry because now Arthur's in a bad way and John won't do anything cause he thinks Arthur isn't...*cries*
...You're sadist you know that?
A talented writer, but a sadist all the same....
Keep it up! =^_^=
person Croik
schedule September 20, 2005 at 12:00 AM
When I first saw this fic pop up, and saw the good comments for it, I was have to say I was interested. It wasn't until recently that I found the time to actually sit down with it, and I have to say, it was a great disappointment. The writing could use some polish, not necessarily grammatically, but...just in terms of common sense. Arthur just *walks* out of a military base when the soldiers' backs are turned? And as for character, though some of the original characters (the Shet bros) are genuinely interesting despite unfortunate name choice, the rest are OOC to the point of I'm wondering if you've even played the games. Big Boss and Ocelot are just so...shallow in this fic, fussing over medals and fighting through petty love triangles. Not to mention Ocelot doesn't miss--and even if he did, he certainly wouldn't pass it off with, "My aim must be off." His aim is his life.


Arthur, to me, seems like a complete Stu--no, he's really more of Sue, actually. It's one thing to be good at what you do and catch the eye of a canon character, but he's good at EVERYTHING and even Ocelot, who betrayed and killed his own best friend, demands that he love him? And what's with the "being married is different than liking women"? This "You rape women for pleasure? Ew--no offense, of course, 'cause I wouldn't want to judge you for raping women" ? Slash fan or not I think your views on females need to be readjusted.


Overall...I'm sorry I can't give you any constructive criticism, but I honestly don't think there's much you can do to help it, and you've already written so much so it's a little late for that anyway. But for you next fic, I suggest not using Wikipedia for your research, and...maybe playing the games a few more times.
person Komikitty
schedule September 13, 2005 at 12:00 AM
O_O *whimper*
Please tell me the ending will be happy?
But very cool! Keep updating!
=^_^=
person Komikitty
schedule September 5, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Sorry I haven't kept up...but...Geeeeeeze....Poor Arthur...Poor John...Stupid men...

Fantastic chapters!
But Was Ocelot in Arthurs room?
Was it one of the brothers trying to get him back?
You're killing me with suspense here!

Please keep up the good work! =^_^=
person shiver with antici--pation.
schedule September 5, 2005 at 12:00 AM
bring the porn already. come on now.
person Komikitty
schedule August 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
O_O NOOOO! I WILL KILL OCELOT! Right after I finish maiming Arthur and Big Boss.
MEN! I swear Testosterone is the worst poison there is! Good job on writing that scene.
Pleeeeeaaaase tell me this is as bad as it gets? Poor John....Poor Arthur...DAMN OCELOT!
But that was a very good, if very creepy, chapter.
Keep up the good work!
=^_^=
person Komikitty
schedule July 26, 2005 at 12:00 AM
O_O wow...Now I'm really worried....Arthur and BB...they stay together right? Ocelot get's whats coming to him...right? Applause for you, a very tense and moody chapter. much different in tone from the first few. =^_^=